For me, a god film is a good story; This is the most important thing. A story with sense, even absurd sense. Famous or unknown actors, director, producers, etc. Either matter the topic: action, romantic, comedy...When you have a good story you have a 50% of the film. I think in cinema of Iran, with Abbas Kiarostami. This guy tell simple stories, with anonymous people. He tell the story only with images and sounds. You don't need to know persian for understand the movie.
A good film relate the drama of the real life, and for that is politic. Taxi driver(Scorsese), The clockwork orange(Kubrick), In the name of the father(Sheridan), Citizen Kane(Welles), Where the green ants dream(Hezog),Tricks(Jakimowski), Bycicle thieves(De Sica), Apocalypse now(Coppola) and many more films do have inm common the story of one persons and his development from the beginning to the end.
A film don't try to tell a new story, if not, how to tell the same story. The essential on different topics of movies is very similar, but the talent for communicate and transmit a concept is unique.
I attached "The Chorus" of Kiarostami, a short film that no need subtitles for be understand:
Part 1
Part 2